Appendix
by the Publisher
|
The Ahmadiyya
Movement as the West sees it
|
Under this heading, near the close of the main body of this book, Maulana
Muhammad Ali has collected extracts from the writings of Western scholars
regarding the Ahmadiyya Movement and its Founder. This Appendix gives
some further extracts on the subject from more recent Western opinion.
- In the New Edition of the Encyclopaedia of Islam (Luzac &
Co., London, 1960), compiled by a board of eminent Western orientalists,
Professor Wilfred Cantwell Smith says of the Ahmadiyya Anjuman Isha’at
Islam, Lahore:
"It has been active in a systematic and effective fashion,
chiefly in three overlapping fields: publishing, organised foreign
missionary work, and leadership in intellectual modernism (liberalism)
in Islam, especially of English-reading Islam. It has produced and
circulated throughout the world (chiefly in English and Urdu, but
also in a half-dozen and more other European and well over a dozen
Asian languages) translations of the Quran, lives of Muhammad, impressive
expositions of Islam, many monographs and essays, and innumerable
pamphlets. Its foreign missions, in London, Berlin, Indonesia, have
been influential . . ." (Under entry Ahmadiyya, p. 302, column
2.)
- Freeland Abbott, in his study of the modern history of Islam in
Pakistan and in pre-partition India, entitled Islam and Pakistan
(Cornell University Press, U.S.A., 1968), makes the following
comments:
"In the third part [of Barahin Ahmadiyya], published
in 1882, Ghulam Ahmad claimed to have received a revelation from
God that he was the great reformer of Islam’s fourteenth century
- the mujaddid of his time . . . Even this does not seem
to have disturbed the traditionalist theologians - an indication,
perhaps, of the respect with which they accepted his book" (p. 150).
"Ghulam Ahmad’s efforts were not only defensive; he took the
offensive as well, and established an extensive, highly organised
missionary enterprise to carry the truths of Islam as he understood
them to all parts of the world" (p. 152).
"The primary significance of the Ahmadiyya movement lay in its
missionary emphasis . . . The Ahmadiyyas made it part of their
principles . . . to proselytise energetically for Islam . . .
"In the course of time the Ahmadiyya arguments against other
religions were wholeheartedly accepted by even their most vociferous
[Muslim] critics . . . Through the vigour of their proselytising
and their incessant and highly publicised attacks on Christianity,
they instilled a stronger faith in many Muslims. They developed
a confident belief that Christianity does not explain the strength
of Europe, and that the true religion remained Islam . . . This
is the essential significance of the Ahmadiyya Movement. It is
somewhat ironic that the sect most attacked by Muslims in India
and Pakistan has also been that which has worked the hardest,
in both its branches, to defend and extend Islam against the competition
offered by other faiths" (pp. 160, 161).
|